Gallstones: symptoms, your scan report, and when surgery is actually needed
Written for someone holding an ultrasound report that says gallstones and wondering what happens next. What they are, how to tell whether they are causing your symptoms, what each line of your scan report means, and why a great many people with gallstones should be watched rather than operated on.
What gallstones are and where they come from
The gallbladder is a small pouch under the right side of the liver whose only function is storage. The liver produces bile continuously, the gallbladder holds it, concentrates it, and squeezes it into the intestine when a fatty meal arrives to help digest the fat. It is a holding tank, not a factory, which is why it can be removed without replacing anything.
Bile is a solution carrying cholesterol, bile salts, bile pigments and calcium. Stones form when that solution becomes too concentrated for what it is carrying, so material comes out of solution and crystallizes, and when the gallbladder does not empty briskly enough to flush those crystals out before they grow. Concentration plus stasis is the whole mechanism.
Three types exist. Cholesterol stones are the commonest by far, usually yellowish, and form when bile carries more cholesterol than its bile salts can keep dissolved. Pigment stones are small, dark and hard, and form where there is excess bile pigment, classically in chronic hemolytic conditions where red cells break down faster than normal. Mixed stones are a combination and account for a large share of what is actually found at surgery.
Stones can be single or number in the hundreds. Size ranges from grains of sand, reported on scans as sludge or microlithiasis, to stones of several centimetres. Counterintuitively, size does not track with how much trouble they cause, and the reason for that is explained further down.
Who tends to get them
- Being female, particularly during childbearing years, because oestrogen increases cholesterol in bile while progesterone slows gallbladder emptying.
- Pregnancy, and more so multiple pregnancies, through the same hormonal mechanism.
- Increasing age, with prevalence rising steadily through adult life.
- Obesity, and separately rapid weight loss, including after crash dieting or bariatric surgery, which mobilises cholesterol and slows gallbladder emptying at the same time.
- Diabetes and the metabolic syndrome.
- A family history of gallstones, which is a genuine and underappreciated factor.
- A diet heavy in fried food and saturated fat, with low fiber. This describes a great deal of ordinary cooking in this region, which is one reason gallstone disease fills general surgical clinics here.
- Prolonged fasting or skipping meals, since a gallbladder that is not asked to empty sits full of concentrated bile.
- Chronic hemolytic conditions such as thalassaemia and sickle cell disease, which cause pigment stones, often in younger patients.
Symptoms
What gallbladder pain is, and what it is not
This is the most useful section on the page, because more unnecessary gallbladder operations follow from misreading this than from anything else.
Biliary colic, the genuine article
A stone temporarily blocks the gallbladder outlet and the organ contracts hard against the obstruction. What the patient experiences has a recognizable signature:
- Severe and steady, not a colicky wave despite the name. It builds over several minutes, plateaus, and eventually fades.
- Under the right ribs or in the upper middle abdomen, often spreading through to the back or up to the tip of the right shoulder blade.
- Starting within an hour or two of a rich meal, classically fried food, ghee, cream, mutton or eggs, and very often at night.
- Lasting from half an hour to a few hours, then going completely, leaving the person well between attacks.
- Making you restless, sweating, sometimes vomiting. People pace or curl up rather than lying still.
Once these attacks start they tend to recur, and each carries a risk of progressing to something worse. That recurrence, rather than the presence of stones on a scan, is the reason to operate.
Symptoms that are probably not your gallbladder
Patients arrive convinced their stones are to blame, frequently because someone told them so, when the description does not fit at all. The following point elsewhere:
- Burning behind the breastbone, worse lying flat or bending over, with acid coming up into the throat. That is reflux.
- Gnawing upper abdominal pain relieved by eating or by antacids, which suggests gastritis or peptic ulcer disease.
- Bloating and discomfort after every meal regardless of fat content, with wind and altered bowel habit. That pattern suggests a functional bowel disorder.
- Pain present all day, every day, for weeks. Biliary colic comes in discrete attacks with well periods between. Constant daily pain is rarely biliary.
- Pain that moves around the abdomen or is felt mainly low down.
Silent gallstones are common enough that they coexist with all of these by coincidence. A scan showing stones does not prove they are the cause, and removing a gallbladder from someone whose problem was reflux leaves them with the same symptoms and one fewer organ. The pattern of your pain matters more than the scan, which is why a proper history takes longer than the examination.
When it gets serious
The complications, and how urgent each one is
Most of what makes gallstones worth treating is not the pain of an attack but what an attack can turn into.
Acute cholecystitis
The blockage does not release, so the trapped gallbladder becomes inflamed and then infected. The pain stops coming and going and instead stays, fever appears, and pressing under the right ribs becomes intensely tender. Treated with antibiotics, fluids and surgery either during that admission or after the attack settles, depending on how long symptoms have been present.
Stones in the common bile duct
A stone escapes into the duct carrying bile from liver to intestine and blocks it. The whites of the eyes then the skin turn yellow, urine darkens, stools go pale, and itching often follows. The duct is cleared, usually endoscopically by ERCP, and the gallbladder is then removed so it cannot send another stone down the same path.
Cholangitis
Infection of an obstructed bile duct. Fever with shaking chills, jaundice and upper abdominal pain together. This is a medical emergency and can deteriorate quickly, particularly in older and diabetic patients.
Gallstone pancreatitis
A stone passing through the duct inflames the pancreas, producing severe upper abdominal pain boring through to the back, with vomiting. An emergency, and once settled the gallbladder should come out, ideally during the same hospital stay, because the risk of a second and worse attack while waiting is significant.
Empyema and gangrene of the gallbladder
An untreated infected gallbladder fills with pus or its wall loses its blood supply and dies. Both need urgent surgery, both are considerably more dangerous than a planned operation, and both are what late presentation eventually produces.
Gallbladder cancer
Uncommon, but the reason polyps of 10 mm or more, polyps growing on repeat scans, and a calcified gallbladder wall are removed even without symptoms. Long standing stones and chronic inflammation are associated with it.
Do not wait for a clinic appointment for these
Fever with shaking chills, yellowing of the eyes or skin, pain that stays rather than passing, persistent vomiting, or severe pain boring through to the back. Go to the nearest hospital and telephone 0336 593 5765.
Your scan
How to read your ultrasound report
Most patients are handed a report full of measurements nobody explains. Here is what the lines that matter actually mean. This is to help you understand your own report, not to replace someone interpreting it alongside your symptoms.
| What the report says | What it means |
|---|---|
| Cholelithiasis | The medical term for gallstones. Often followed by the number and size seen. |
| Multiple calculi, or a single calculus | How many stones. The count matters less than you would expect. Many small stones are arguably more dangerous than one large one, because a small stone can escape into the bile duct while a large one physically cannot. |
| Sludge, or microlithiasis | Thickened bile with crystals, short of formed stones. It can cause identical attacks and can still pass into the duct. |
| Gallbladder wall thickness | Normally up to about 3 mm. Thickening suggests inflammation, either acute or from repeated past attacks. A thick walled gallbladder is usually a harder one to remove. |
| Pericholecystic fluid | Fluid collected around the gallbladder, which points to active inflammation. Taken together with pain, fever and tenderness this suggests acute cholecystitis. |
| Contracted gallbladder | Shrunken, often scarred from repeated inflammation. Sometimes simply means you had eaten before the scan, which is why these are done fasting. |
| Distended gallbladder | Enlarged and tense, which can indicate obstruction at the outlet. |
| Common bile duct, CBD, diameter | The important one. Normally up to about 6 mm, a little wider with age or after the gallbladder has been removed. A dilated duct raises the question of a stone within it, which changes the whole plan and usually prompts liver function tests and MRCP. |
| Gallbladder polyp | A growth on the wall. Under 10 mm and not growing, these are usually watched with periodic scans. At 10 mm or more, or growing, removal is advised. |
| Porcelain gallbladder | A calcified wall. Associated with a raised cancer risk and an indication for removal. |
| Impacted stone in the neck or Hartmann's pouch | A stone stuck at the outlet. More likely to be causing your symptoms, and more likely to have provoked inflammation. |
| Fatty liver, hepatic steatosis | A common incidental finding, unrelated to your stones, worth addressing separately with diet and weight. |
Why stone size matters less than people assume
Patients frequently arrive focused on a measurement, believing a 15 mm stone must be more serious than a 4 mm one. The logic is reasonable and the conclusion is wrong.
A large stone is physically incapable of leaving the gallbladder through the cystic duct. It sits there, causes attacks when it obstructs the outlet, and stays put. Small stones are the ones that can slip out into the common bile duct, and that is where the dangerous complications live: obstructive jaundice, cholangitis and gallstone pancreatitis. So a gallbladder full of small stones and sludge often carries more risk than one containing a single large stone.
Size matters in one direction only. Stones over about 3 cm, and a calcified wall, are associated with a higher risk of gallbladder cancer, which is why they weigh towards removal even in the absence of symptoms.
Other tests you may be sent for
- Liver function tests, to look for the pattern of a blocked bile duct. Raised bilirubin and alkaline phosphatase change the plan.
- MRCP, a magnetic resonance scan of the bile ducts, when a duct stone is suspected. Detailed and non invasive.
- ERCP, an endoscopic procedure that both finds and removes stones from the bile duct. Therapeutic rather than merely diagnostic, and used when a duct stone is likely rather than merely possible.
- CT scan, poor at showing gallstones themselves but useful for complications and for looking at the pancreas.
- Blood count, amylase or lipase, and clotting, depending on the presentation.
The decision
Operate, or watch and wait
The honest position, which a surgical practice has no commercial incentive to state, is that a great many people with gallstones should not have an operation.
Stones with no symptoms, ever
If your stones were found incidentally on a scan done for something else and you have never had the pain, observation is usually the right answer. Community studies following people with silent gallstones over years consistently show the majority never develop symptoms at all. Operating on everybody with stones on a scan would mean a great deal of surgery on people who were never going to need it.
There are exceptions where removal is advised despite the absence of symptoms: polyps of 10 mm or more or growing on repeat scans, a calcified porcelain gallbladder, stones over about 3 cm, and certain situations where a patient is undergoing other abdominal surgery anyway or faces limited access to emergency care.
Once the attacks have started
The picture changes, because recurrence is the rule rather than the exception and each episode carries a chance of progressing to cholecystitis, a duct stone or pancreatitis. Those present as emergencies, at times nobody chooses, with higher risk than a planned operation. There is also a surgical argument: a gallbladder that has been inflamed repeatedly becomes thick walled, scarred and adherent to what surrounds it, which turns a straightforward day case into a longer and more difficult operation with a greater chance of needing a larger incision. Treating early is easier than treating late.
Can stones be dissolved or passed instead?
Bile acid tablets such as ursodeoxycholic acid genuinely can dissolve stones, but only small, purely cholesterol ones in a gallbladder that still empties well. Treatment runs for months to years, succeeds in a minority of carefully selected patients, and stones recur in a large proportion once tablets stop, because the gallbladder that made them is unchanged. Shock wave lithotripsy, which works well for kidney stones, has largely been abandoned for the gallbladder for the same reason.
Herbal flushes and olive oil with lemon regimens do not dissolve stones. The soft green pellets that appear in the stool afterwards are saponified oil, not stones, and the stones remain clearly visible on a repeat scan. This matters because patients lose months to them and sometimes arrive eventually with an infected gallbladder that would have been a simple day case earlier.
Diet control is genuinely worthwhile, but understand what it does. Avoiding fried food, ghee, cream and rich meat, eating smaller and more regular meals rather than skipping them, increasing fiber, and losing weight gradually rather than crash dieting will all reduce how often you get attacks. None of it removes a stone.
Where surgery is the answer, the full patient guide to the operation is here, and the single incision technique used in this practice is explained here.
اگر پتے میں پتھری ہے لیکن کبھی درد نہیں ہوا تو عام طور پر آپریشن کی ضرورت نہیں ہوتی، صرف نگرانی کافی ہے۔ لیکن جب درد کے دورے شروع ہو جائیں تو ہر دورے کے ساتھ پتے میں انفیکشن، نالی میں پتھری یا پینکریاس کی سوزش کا خطرہ بڑھتا ہے۔ جڑی بوٹیوں یا زیتون کے تیل سے پتھری نہیں گھلتی۔
Questions
What patients ask
Can gallstones go away on their own?
Formed stones do not disappear. Sludge and very small crystals can clear, sometimes by passing into the intestine, which is not without risk since that is the route to a blocked bile duct or pancreatitis. Anyone telling you established stones will dissolve with diet is mistaken.
How long can I safely leave it?
If you have genuinely never had symptoms, potentially indefinitely, with review if things change. Once attacks have begun there is no safe interval anyone can promise you, because the next episode may be biliary colic or it may be pancreatitis. Most surgeons advise treating within weeks to a few months rather than years.
Is the pain always after fatty food?
Classically yes, because fat triggers the gallbladder to contract, but not invariably. Attacks also happen at night with no meal beforehand. The absence of a fatty meal does not rule out biliary colic if the rest of the pattern fits.
My scan says sludge, not stones. Does that matter?
It can. Sludge causes identical attacks and can still pass into the bile duct. It is treated according to your symptoms rather than the word on the report: sludge with recurrent biliary attacks is managed much as stones would be, while sludge found incidentally in someone with no symptoms is usually watched.
I am pregnant and have been told I have stones. What now?
Mild symptoms are usually managed conservatively until after delivery. Where attacks are recurrent or there has been pancreatitis, surgery during pregnancy is sometimes the safer course, most often in the second trimester, planned jointly with the obstetric team. It is not undertaken lightly and it is not automatically avoided either.
Will I need a special diet forever after surgery?
No. The liver continues making bile exactly as before, it simply arrives in a steadier trickle rather than a squirt. Take it gently with fried and rich food for the first month, then most people return to normal eating entirely. A small number stay sensitive to very fatty meals and learn where their own limit is.
Do gallstones cause cancer?
Gallbladder cancer is uncommon, and the great majority of people with stones never develop it. Long standing stones, chronic inflammation, stones over about 3 cm, polyps of 10 mm or more and a calcified wall are all associated with higher risk, which is why those specific findings prompt removal even without symptoms.
My whole family has had this. Is it hereditary?
Family history is a genuine risk factor, through inherited differences in how cholesterol is handled in bile. It does not mean you will certainly get stones, and it is worth mentioning at consultation because it raises the likelihood that upper abdominal symptoms are biliary.
Bring the report and find out whether you actually need surgery
A consultation establishes whether your symptoms are coming from the stones at all, and if they are, whether the answer is an operation or observation. If it is observation, that is what you will be told.